When this blog was still just beginning and brand new, I reviewed a novel by Chris Roberson, Book of Secrets. It had just come out from brand-new imprint Angry Robot Books, and was one of the first ARC copies of a book I had ever received. I was very excited, dove into it, and loved it up until the very end, where I felt it lost a bit of its luster from an ending that didn’t cut it for me. That said, I loved the journey, and really wanted to give Roberson another try. I had a copy of another of his novels, Dawn of War II, but it was packed up, and I never got around to reading it, but when his latest book came in the mail, I knew it was time to check out this author again.
On a backwater planet, a three-sided war is being fought. Yet, right in the middle of the conflict, Space Marines drop down from the sky, take a couple thousand youths, and depart. The Imperial Fists were on a recruiting mission. Among those picked out are Zatori Zan, Taloc s’Tonan, and Jean-Robur du Queste, three young men from three different sides of the war. Yet, as people are gradually weeded out by the recruitment process, these three continue to remain. When they are called to defend civilians on the planet Vernalis, they answer the call. But can they withstand the combined forces of the Roaring Blades Traitor Guard, the Emporer’s Children Chaos Marines, and a host of daemons?
This book begins with the waging of war on their home planet, then flows into the training of a space marine, before we are given the epic warfare we seek. Roberson does a very good job of laying down the characters and setting up the conflict, before dumping everyone in the training regime, where we see the brutality of what it takes to be a Space Marine. The action scenes are spot on, if a little over-drawn-out at times, but Roberson excels at his characterization. His characters never act or speak in a way that didn’t fit who they were.
Once again, I find the ending left a little to be asked for. How things played out for our three main characters, as well as for the host of minor ones, felt a little too convenient at times, along with two back-to-back instances of people showing up at the exact perfect moment. While this is the first book in a new series, and killing off your main characters wouldn’t be a wise choice, things just seemed to work out a little too well for realism’s sake.
All-in-all, though, this is a book worth reading. I had fun with it. It wasn’t great, but it was good, and there are far worse things than that. I have a feeling that Roberson will present us with a good series to come. I hope that he steps away from the excessive far-too-convenient moments, or at least tame them down a bit, but I also hope that he sticks with his work on characterization. I felt that, with Sons of Dorn, Roberson distanced himself from most of the other authors of Warhammer 40,000 in creating some of the most fully fleshed-out characters I’ve seen out of Warhammer 40,000. This was a welcome change to the seeming over-reliance on occasion to characters that are fun but lack real depth. Roberson has set up a good start to what I think can be a great series.
(Note: While Sons of Dorn receives the same score as Book of Secrets did, two things should be kept in mind. First, I was very lenient in early reviews, and gave much higher grades than I perhaps should have, as I was still getting my feet under me. Second, the recent new rules for the grade scale (seen on the left) give what at first seems a far harsher score, but I think a much more honest one that makes it easier to pick a good book.)
7/10
Tuesday, February 2, 2010
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Flight by Sherman Alexie
Part of starting up Luke Reviews was to read books that aren’t quite in my usual repertoire. This has been something that has greatly expanded my reading enjoyment. Books like Killer Summer, Bad Things Happen, The Hidden Man, and a number of others fall into a realm where I don’t read much, and directly contributed to other books I picked up afterwards, like The Mysterious Affair at Styles. Keeping that in mind, here is another book that is a little off the radar. It has a fantastical plot element, to be sure, although that isn’t the point of the plot.
Zits isn’t happy. After his father abandoned him and his mother died, he has gone from foster home to foster home, never settling down, never living a good life. After repeatedly going to jail, he finally bumps into Justice, another inmate and the first person Zits felt really cared for him since the death of his mom. However, Justice is brainwashing Zits, culminating in the unthinkable: Zits walks into a bank and guns down every person inside. But as he is shot in the head by guards, he falls back in time, and begins an odyssey that explores hate, violence, forgiveness, and love.
Sherman Alexie is right up there with Leslie Marmon Silko and James Welch among Native American writers. Having read books from each of the others, Alexie brings the tale of race and difference and wanting to belong without having to be what you aren’t to a far more human and wonderful level. His character sees the conflict from both Native American and white perspectives, and is far from the gross stereotypes of either violent warmonger of noble savage that seems so common in modern fiction.
The story is very episodic, yet each episode flows into the other in a very organic way, making complete sense and fitting together like pieces of a puzzle. As each trip in the past gives Zits a more complex picture of the world, he shows a breadth of change that is quite vast, yet never feels unnatural. In a very short novel, Alexie makes his character accessible and human, and doesn’t have to sacrifice the story to do so.
This was a definite step outside the box for Luke Reviews, but strongly recommended. It is a slightly different offering, yet it still does contain the action and adventure that you see in most Luke Reviews titles. But like the best of those reviewed here, it surpasses genre, and is a good story.
8/10
Zits isn’t happy. After his father abandoned him and his mother died, he has gone from foster home to foster home, never settling down, never living a good life. After repeatedly going to jail, he finally bumps into Justice, another inmate and the first person Zits felt really cared for him since the death of his mom. However, Justice is brainwashing Zits, culminating in the unthinkable: Zits walks into a bank and guns down every person inside. But as he is shot in the head by guards, he falls back in time, and begins an odyssey that explores hate, violence, forgiveness, and love.
Sherman Alexie is right up there with Leslie Marmon Silko and James Welch among Native American writers. Having read books from each of the others, Alexie brings the tale of race and difference and wanting to belong without having to be what you aren’t to a far more human and wonderful level. His character sees the conflict from both Native American and white perspectives, and is far from the gross stereotypes of either violent warmonger of noble savage that seems so common in modern fiction.
The story is very episodic, yet each episode flows into the other in a very organic way, making complete sense and fitting together like pieces of a puzzle. As each trip in the past gives Zits a more complex picture of the world, he shows a breadth of change that is quite vast, yet never feels unnatural. In a very short novel, Alexie makes his character accessible and human, and doesn’t have to sacrifice the story to do so.
This was a definite step outside the box for Luke Reviews, but strongly recommended. It is a slightly different offering, yet it still does contain the action and adventure that you see in most Luke Reviews titles. But like the best of those reviewed here, it surpasses genre, and is a good story.
8/10
Saturday, January 30, 2010
The Next Ten
I used to run a series of posts entitled “A Hint of What’s to Come.” It just gave a look at the upcoming books. Despite being a nice look ahead, I went a little overboard, made huge lists that were impossible to keep my interests stuck to, and with the last one didn’t even come close to keeping it up. So, with a new idea comes a new title. “The Next Ten” will give you glimpses into what ten books I’m looking at reading next. It isn’t to say that there won’t be a few things in between these ten books, because small things come up, but Luke Reviews promises to get to these books in the very near future, only interrupting the order long enough to review an exciting book that just couldn’t wait, before resuming the flow. Here are Luke Reviews’ Next Ten (Title by Author (date of publication of edition read/publisher of edition read):
Flight by Sherman Alexie (2007/Black Cat)
Sons of Dorn by Chris Roberson (2010/Black Library)
The Coming Race by Edward Bulwer-Lytton (2002/Broadview Press)
Rynn’s World by Steve Parker (2010/Black Library)
Explorer X – Alpha by L. M. Preston (2010/Phenomenal One Press)
Snow Angels by James Thompson (2010/Putnam)
Molly Fyde and the Land of Light by Hugh Howey (2010/Broad Reach Publishing)
Gran’s Secret by Trevis Powell (2010/BlackWyrm)
Death & Dishonour edited by Alex Davis, Nick Kyme, and Lindsey Priestley (2010/Black Library)
Call to Arms by Mitchel Scanlon (2010/Black Library)
These are the Next Ten at Luke Reviews, but as said above, smaller projects will get slipped in between. Look for reviews of “Raven’s Flight,” the new Black Library audio drama by Gav Thorpe, as well as some classic Marvel cosmic action!
Flight by Sherman Alexie (2007/Black Cat)
Sons of Dorn by Chris Roberson (2010/Black Library)
The Coming Race by Edward Bulwer-Lytton (2002/Broadview Press)
Rynn’s World by Steve Parker (2010/Black Library)
Explorer X – Alpha by L. M. Preston (2010/Phenomenal One Press)
Snow Angels by James Thompson (2010/Putnam)
Molly Fyde and the Land of Light by Hugh Howey (2010/Broad Reach Publishing)
Gran’s Secret by Trevis Powell (2010/BlackWyrm)
Death & Dishonour edited by Alex Davis, Nick Kyme, and Lindsey Priestley (2010/Black Library)
Call to Arms by Mitchel Scanlon (2010/Black Library)
These are the Next Ten at Luke Reviews, but as said above, smaller projects will get slipped in between. Look for reviews of “Raven’s Flight,” the new Black Library audio drama by Gav Thorpe, as well as some classic Marvel cosmic action!
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
Avengers: Kree/Skrull War by Roy Thomas
I spent quite a bit of time trying to get a real grasp of the cosmic milieu of the Marvel Universe, and hit on the major texts of the ‘90s (minus Operation: Galactic Storm, which is a two-volume tale to keep your eyes out for a review of on here). However, a lot of important events that set the foundation of the cosmic universe happened in the ‘70s, and I wanted to take a look at them as well. The two classic stories I wanted to make sure and not miss were the Kree/Skrull War storyline that ran through Avengers, and the Dark Phoenix Saga storyline that ran through X-Men. Combined, the two stories address all three of the major space empires in the universe, and looked like solid foundational reads, beyond being classics of the genre. The first one I took a look at was the Kree/Skrull storyline, collected in Avengers: Kree/Skrull War.
Beginning with a exiled Kree warrior on the run on Earth, snowballing into Kree attempt at annihilating humanity and a Skrull attempt at kidnapping Kree, “Earth’s Mightiest Heroes,” the Avengers, team together to fight political maneuvers to trap them in a conspiracy theory plot, save the Kree-spawned race of Inhumans, keep the exiled Kree Captain Marvel safe from the government and the Skrulls, and stop a war between the Kree and Skrull Empires, the two greatest space faring peoples in the Universe.
While this book does occasionally show its age, mainly with its art style and the exclamations (e.g. “Faaaaan-tastic!”), the story itself doesn’t feel out of place with today’s comics at all. While it has far more “reading” than action-oriented art that is seen today, it helped give the story a much broader sense of appeal. It did occasionally slow things down, but when things hit their head, the pace is breathtaking. Definitely a book that starts slow as it builds up to its real plot, but explodes when things start to get rolling.
Characterization of some of the characters isn’t fully-fleshed, due to this being a small segment of a very long and storied comic narrative, but it is very easy to quickly pick up who’s who, and where any tensions lie. The newer characters get a more exacting characterization, and when you don’t find out much, you can tell that it is on purpose, to retain the mystery.
Avengers: Kree/Skrull War is a classic. For today’s comic reader, you might find it a tad dated in parts, and a little slow going occasionally. The denouement is more than worth working through the slow beginning, though, and I encourage you to keep at it. A great starting point for those interested in the history of the cosmic realm explored in Annihilation, Annihilation: Conquest, War of Kings, and the ongoing Realm of Kings.
7/10
Beginning with a exiled Kree warrior on the run on Earth, snowballing into Kree attempt at annihilating humanity and a Skrull attempt at kidnapping Kree, “Earth’s Mightiest Heroes,” the Avengers, team together to fight political maneuvers to trap them in a conspiracy theory plot, save the Kree-spawned race of Inhumans, keep the exiled Kree Captain Marvel safe from the government and the Skrulls, and stop a war between the Kree and Skrull Empires, the two greatest space faring peoples in the Universe.
While this book does occasionally show its age, mainly with its art style and the exclamations (e.g. “Faaaaan-tastic!”), the story itself doesn’t feel out of place with today’s comics at all. While it has far more “reading” than action-oriented art that is seen today, it helped give the story a much broader sense of appeal. It did occasionally slow things down, but when things hit their head, the pace is breathtaking. Definitely a book that starts slow as it builds up to its real plot, but explodes when things start to get rolling.
Characterization of some of the characters isn’t fully-fleshed, due to this being a small segment of a very long and storied comic narrative, but it is very easy to quickly pick up who’s who, and where any tensions lie. The newer characters get a more exacting characterization, and when you don’t find out much, you can tell that it is on purpose, to retain the mystery.
Avengers: Kree/Skrull War is a classic. For today’s comic reader, you might find it a tad dated in parts, and a little slow going occasionally. The denouement is more than worth working through the slow beginning, though, and I encourage you to keep at it. A great starting point for those interested in the history of the cosmic realm explored in Annihilation, Annihilation: Conquest, War of Kings, and the ongoing Realm of Kings.
7/10
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
The Top 15: An Update
After announcing the Top 15 not too long ago, along with author comments, I thought I was done with the list, but I just received an email from Harry Dolan, author of Bad Things Happen, with his comments on his first novel being listed in the Luke Reviews Top 15 of 2009.
From Harry Dolan: I'm grateful to see that you've chosen Bad Things Happen as one of your Top 15. I feel very fortunate that readers and critics have responded to the book as strongly as they have. I'm working on a follow-up now, which will once again feature David Loogan and Elizabeth Waishkey. The tentative title is Very Bad Men. It should be out in early 2011.
I hope you guys enjoyed hearing from the authors, and I can’t wait to see what 2010 brings!
From Harry Dolan: I'm grateful to see that you've chosen Bad Things Happen as one of your Top 15. I feel very fortunate that readers and critics have responded to the book as strongly as they have. I'm working on a follow-up now, which will once again feature David Loogan and Elizabeth Waishkey. The tentative title is Very Bad Men. It should be out in early 2011.
I hope you guys enjoyed hearing from the authors, and I can’t wait to see what 2010 brings!
Monday, January 25, 2010
Ill Met in the Arena by Dave Duncan
Apparently Dave Duncan is quite the fantasy author. He has written a ton of books, and received quite a lot of acclaim. So how is it that I never heard of this fellow until I picked up Ill Met in the Arena, his fortieth book? And I thought I knew my way around the SF/F section… Anyways, This is a bit of an anti-review.
Ill Met in the Arena follows an aged arena competitor who has a secret past. He battles and bests a noble and this brings him to the attention of a lot of people. In a world where women rule and everyone has some sort of psychic ability, this tale of political intrigue and action weaves in one nameless man’s tale that is at the root of the society.
I didn’t finish Ill Met in the Arena. That said, it isn’t even remotely the novel’s fault. The new semester is just starting up, I moved back in after being gone for a few weeks on vacation, and just to top it all off, I got bit by a dog. Life came hard and fast for a bit, and kept me away from the book too long. With classes about to begin, and new books on the horizon, I didn’t want to have to restart everything, so I’m setting the book aside for a little bit. I will be back, and will tell you all about the experience. For now, Ill Met in the Arena will receive no numerical rating.
That said, from the first half of the book (which I did finish), this is one very much worth picking up. It is brilliantly written, with an intriguing society (even if, in its attempt to reverse gender role stereotypes, it manages to reinforce them in other cases) and characters that are beyond humanlike. The depth of characterization is truly masterful. This is a book I highly recommend based on what I have read, and I will certainly be keeping an eye out for Dave Duncan in the future.
Ill Met in the Arena follows an aged arena competitor who has a secret past. He battles and bests a noble and this brings him to the attention of a lot of people. In a world where women rule and everyone has some sort of psychic ability, this tale of political intrigue and action weaves in one nameless man’s tale that is at the root of the society.
I didn’t finish Ill Met in the Arena. That said, it isn’t even remotely the novel’s fault. The new semester is just starting up, I moved back in after being gone for a few weeks on vacation, and just to top it all off, I got bit by a dog. Life came hard and fast for a bit, and kept me away from the book too long. With classes about to begin, and new books on the horizon, I didn’t want to have to restart everything, so I’m setting the book aside for a little bit. I will be back, and will tell you all about the experience. For now, Ill Met in the Arena will receive no numerical rating.
That said, from the first half of the book (which I did finish), this is one very much worth picking up. It is brilliantly written, with an intriguing society (even if, in its attempt to reverse gender role stereotypes, it manages to reinforce them in other cases) and characters that are beyond humanlike. The depth of characterization is truly masterful. This is a book I highly recommend based on what I have read, and I will certainly be keeping an eye out for Dave Duncan in the future.
Saturday, January 23, 2010
Cadian Blood by Aaron Dembski-Bowden
Warhammer 40,000 is a diverse setting. Beyond the obvious infinite possibilities of an Empire of millions of worlds, the built-in settings for series of books give a number of options. Like the space marines? Then there are series galore: Ultramarines, Blood Angels, Grey Knights, Soul Drinkers, Dawn of War (aka Blood Ravens), Space Wolf, Salamanders, Imperial Fist, etc. If that isn’t your cup of tea, you can focus on the Inquisition, as they fight heresy. Series include the Eisenhorn trilogy, the Ravenor trilogy, the Inquisition War trilogy, and the new Bastion Wars series. Luke Reviews has delved into both of those segments, but never before have I looked at the Imperial Guard novels, a series of stand-alone books that follow the men who aren’t enhanced war machines or religious fanatics. So it was about time to give the Imperial Guard a look.
On the planet Kathur, Chaos has overrun the populace, killing many and leaving the rest viciously ill. Those who die wracked with this disease don’t stay dead; they rise up again, and conquer the world in the name of Chaos. Reclaiming the planet seems like it should be a minor ordeal of blasting the planet from space, but things get complicated. Kathur is named after Saint Kathur, hero of the Great Crusade, and full of relics of his life. The Empire refuses to let these holy sites be destroyed, and instead send in a series of guardsmen to recover Kathur. Among them are the Cadian 88th Mechanized Infantry, in part led by Captain Thade. They must survive the onslaught of plague-ridden zombies if they hope to return home.
This book has been getting seemingly nothing but good reviews, so I was very excited to give it a look. This of course made me even more baffled than normal when the beginning just fell flat, due to excessive amounts of telling and not showing (“Don’t tell the reader, show them”). It was dry and not at all engaging for the first 20 or so pages. A recap of the history of the planet, and the onset of the Plague of Unbelief.
And then Cadian Blood took off. Once the story set into place, it was brilliant. Dembski-Bowden hits every part right, creating very memorable characters in Thade and his lieutenants, creating a flow of action that never let up, and making the story incredibly easy to find yourself drawn into. Almost unparalleled in Warhammer 40,000 fiction, Dembski-Bowden’s first novel brings the realities of war in this setting to life, and he doesn’t hold back.
One minor quibble that I had was his choice of announcing that certain characters would die before they actually did in the story, as well as a slight lull about two-thirds of the way through, but otherwise Cadian Blood was a brilliant work. I am very much excited about Dembski-Bowden’s next novel, Soul Hunter.
8/10
On the planet Kathur, Chaos has overrun the populace, killing many and leaving the rest viciously ill. Those who die wracked with this disease don’t stay dead; they rise up again, and conquer the world in the name of Chaos. Reclaiming the planet seems like it should be a minor ordeal of blasting the planet from space, but things get complicated. Kathur is named after Saint Kathur, hero of the Great Crusade, and full of relics of his life. The Empire refuses to let these holy sites be destroyed, and instead send in a series of guardsmen to recover Kathur. Among them are the Cadian 88th Mechanized Infantry, in part led by Captain Thade. They must survive the onslaught of plague-ridden zombies if they hope to return home.
This book has been getting seemingly nothing but good reviews, so I was very excited to give it a look. This of course made me even more baffled than normal when the beginning just fell flat, due to excessive amounts of telling and not showing (“Don’t tell the reader, show them”). It was dry and not at all engaging for the first 20 or so pages. A recap of the history of the planet, and the onset of the Plague of Unbelief.
And then Cadian Blood took off. Once the story set into place, it was brilliant. Dembski-Bowden hits every part right, creating very memorable characters in Thade and his lieutenants, creating a flow of action that never let up, and making the story incredibly easy to find yourself drawn into. Almost unparalleled in Warhammer 40,000 fiction, Dembski-Bowden’s first novel brings the realities of war in this setting to life, and he doesn’t hold back.
One minor quibble that I had was his choice of announcing that certain characters would die before they actually did in the story, as well as a slight lull about two-thirds of the way through, but otherwise Cadian Blood was a brilliant work. I am very much excited about Dembski-Bowden’s next novel, Soul Hunter.
8/10
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




